| The series proper, May 1969-April 1974: |
| 9. |
May 1969 | #01602 | The Blue Star | Fletcher Pratt |
| 10. | June 1969 | #01628 | The King of Elfland's Daughter | Lord Dunsany |
| 11. | July 1969 | #01652 | The Wood Beyond the World | William Morris |
| 12. | Aug 1969 | #01678 | The Silver Stallion | James Branch Cabell |
| 13. | Sep 1969 | #01711-2 | Lilith | George MacDonald |
| 14. | Oct 1969 | #01731 | Dragons, Elves, and Heroes | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 15. | Oct 1969 | #01730 | The Young Magicians | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 16. | Nov 1969 | #01763 | Figures of Earth | James Branch Cabell |
| 17. | Dec 1969 | #01795 | The Sorcerer's Ship | Hannes Bok |
| 18. | Jan 1970 | #01814 | Land of Unreason | Fletcher Pratt and L. Sprague de Camp |
| 19. | Feb 1970 | #01855-9 | The High Place | James Branch Cabell |
| 20. | Mar 1970 | #01880-X | Lud-in-the-Mist | Hope Mirrlees |
| 21. | Mar 1970 | #01879-6 | At the Edge of the World | Lord Dunsany |
| 22. | Apr 1970 | #01902-4 | Phantastes | George MacDonald |
| 23. | May 1970 | #01923-7 | The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath | H. P. Lovecraft |
| 24. | June 1970 | #01938-5 | Zothique | Clark Ashton Smith |
| 25. | July 1970 | #01958-X | The Shaving of Shagpat | George Meredith |
| 26. | July 1970 | #01959-8 | The Island of the Mighty | Evangeline Walton |
| 27. | Aug 1970 | #01981-4 | Deryni Rising | Katherine Kurtz |
| 28. | Aug 1970 | #01982-2 | The Well at the World's End Vol. 1 | William Morris |
| 29. | Sep 1970 | #02015-4 | The Well at the World's End Vol. 2 | William Morris |
| 30. | Oct 1970 | #02045-6 | Golden Cities, Far | Lin Carter |
| 31. | Nov 1970 | #02093-6 | Beyond the Golden Stair | Hannes Bok |
| 32. | Jan 1971 | #02107-X | The Broken Sword | Poul Anderson |
| 33. | Feb 1971 | #02145-2 | The Boats of the 'Glen Carrig' | William Hope Hodgson |
| 34. | Feb 1971 | #02146 | The Doom that Came to Sarnath | H. P. Lovecraft |
| 35. | Mar 1971 | #02067-7 | Something About Eve | James Branch Cabell |
| 36. | Mar 1971 | #02178-9 | Red Moon and Black Mountain | Joy Chant |
| 37. | Apr 1971 | #02206-8 | Hyperborea | Clark Ashton Smith |
| 38. | May 1971 | #02244-0 | Don Rodriguez: Chronicles of Shadow Valley | Lord Dunsany |
| 39. | June 1971 | #02279-3 | Vathek | William Beckford |
| 40. | July 1971 | #02305-6 | The Man Who Was Thursday | G. K. Chesterton |
| 41. | Aug 1971 | #02332-3 | The Children of Llyr | Evangeline Walton |
| 42. | Sep 1971 | #02364-1 | The Cream of the Jest | James Branch Cabell |
| 43. | Sep 1971 | #02365-X | New Worlds for Old | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 44. | Oct 1971 | #02394-3 | The Spawn of Cthulhu | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 45. | Nov 1971 | #02420-6 | Double Phoenix | Edmund Cooper and Roger Lancelyn Green |
| 46. | Nov 1971 | #02421-4 | The Water of the Wondrous Isles | William Morris |
| 47. | Dec 1971 | #02446-X | Khaled | F. Marion Crawford |
| 48. | Jan 1972 | #02467-2 | The World's Desire | H. Rider Haggard and Andrew Lang |
| 49. | Feb 1972 | #02427-3 | Lovecraft: A Look Behind the Cthulhu Mythos | Lin Carter |
| 50. | Feb 1972 | #02501-6 | Xiccarph | Clark Ashton Smith |
| 51. | Feb 1972 | #02502-4 | The Lost Continent | C. J. Cutcliffe-Hyne |
| 52. | Mar 1972 | #02546-6 | Discoveries in Fantasy | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 53. | Mar 1972 | #02545-8 | Domnei | James Branch Cabell |
| 54. | Apr 1972 | #02574-1 | Kai Lung's Golden Hours | Ernest Bramah |
| 55. | May 1972 | #02598-9 | Deryni Checkmate | Katherine Kurtz |
| 56. | May 1972 | #02599-7 | Beyond the Fields We Know | Lord Dunsany |
| 57. | June 1972 | #02643-8 | The Three Imposters | Arthur Machen |
| 58. | July 1972 | #02669-1 | The Night Land Vol. 1 | William Hope Hodgson |
| 59. | July 1972 | #02670-5 | The Night Land Vol. 2 | William Hope Hodgson |
| 60. | Aug 1972 | #02773-5 | The Song of Rhiannon | Evangeline Walton |
| 61. | Sep 1972 | #02789-2 | Great Short Novels of Adult Fantasy #1 | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 62. | Nov 1972 | #02874 | Evenor | George MacDonald |
| 63. | Jan 1973 | #03057-5 | Orlando Furioso
(Vol. 1, The Ring of Angelica) | Ludovico Ariosto
Translated by Richard Hodgens |
| 64. | Feb 1973 | #03085-0 | The Charwoman's Shadow | Lord Dunsany |
| 65. | Mar 1973 | #03162-8 | Great Short Novels of Adult Fantasy #2 | Lin Carter, ed. |
| 66. | May 1973 | #03261-6 | The Sundering Flood | William Morris |
| 67. | June 1973 | #03309-4 | Imaginary Worlds | Lin Carter |
| 68. | July 1973 | #03353-1 | Poseidonis | Clark Ashton Smith |
| 69. | Aug 1973 | #23416-2 | Excalibur | Sanders Anne Laubenthal |
| 70. | Sep 1973 | #23485-5 | High Deryni | Katherine Kurtz |
| 71. | Oct 1973 | #23562-2 | Hrolf Kraki's Saga | Poul Anderson |
| (36) | Nov 1973 | #23611-4 | Red Moon and Black Mountain | Joy Chant (prnt2) |
| 72. | Dec 1973 | #23660-2 | The People of the Mist | H. Rider Haggard |
| 73. | Feb 1974 | #023787-0 | Kai Lung Unrolls his Mat | Ernest Bramah |
| 74. | Apr 1974 | #023886-9 | Over the Hills and Far Away | Lord Dunsany |
| 75. | June 1974 | 24010 | Merlin's Ring | H. Warner Munn |